Showing posts with label student-athletes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label student-athletes. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 2, 2011

Giving College Athletes More Money

The debate over whether to provide college athletes with more money than their scholarships will never end. I don’t say that in a negative tone but because it is such a hot button issue.

The issue is in the news again because last week the NCAA made a recommendation that would allow conferences to provide $2000 more to scholarship athletes. I’m somewhat confused on what constitutes the $2000 in value, but I take it the amount wouldn’t be all cash.

Full-ride scholarships presently don’t cover all the expenses/fees the student-athlete occurs. This would help offset those costs. The real costs would come to the particularly university or college. Each school would need to fund student-athletes equally. For example, the softball player couldn’t receive less than the football player or the volleyball player couldn’t receive less than the basketball player.

My concern isn’t equality between sport teams but between conferences. The BCS (or big) schools would probably have no difficulty with the additional expenses. They would just make bigger pitches to the alumni and other supporters of the athletic program. But the small schools in small conferences already struggle to keep pace with the big boys in terms of financial resources. This would place the smaller schools at a greater disadvantage. The big boys already have the pick of the crop in recruiting and this measure would probably continue to provide that deep advantage. Student-athletes considering a school will look hard at the financial package like others pondering a job offer.

So although this recommendation looks good on the outside, it has sticky potential on the inside.

Tuesday, September 21, 2010

Should the NCAA Pay Athletes?

The long standing discussion about whether student-athletes should be paid is gaining steam again.

Former NCAA athletes Ed O’Bannon and Sam Keller have brought lawsuits against the NCAA asking them to share its wealth with the athletes.

O’Bannon and Keller are intelligent enough to realize they are fighting against a billion-dollar industry with mighty clout and mighty lawyers. But even if reform happens in some way, then the fight is worth it.

Players are being paid now. It is just illegal. Boosters, sports agents and others are definitely supplying the money.

The NCAA argues athletes receive scholarships and room and board as a form of payment. I can tell you that Division I athletes aren’t staying at $30 motels or eating at fast food restaurants while on the road

Call me old fashioned, but I am not in favor of the NCAA paying athletes. How could it develop a fair system that would pay athletes on even a somewhat equal system? And frankly when you start actually paying athletes, you have professional sports with a different set of challenges.

I think the NCAA should provide a set number of scholarships to schools’ general fund based on sports Top 25 polls. All schools finishing in the Top 25 at the end of the season would receive the number of scholarships per final ranking. You could take the football and basketball polls for the men and the volleyball and basketballs polls for the women. This would give schools a tremendous boast in an age when major cuts are plaguing colleges and universities finances.

O’Bannon and Keller are providing awareness. Now it is time to put that awareness into action via the courts or some other element.

Do you believe athletes should be paid? Why or why not?