Wednesday, September 22, 2010

Michigan State's Mark Dantonio Teaches Lessons

Michigan State football coach Mark Dantonio experienced major joy and major heartache last Saturday.

Dantonio led his team to an overtime victory past rival Notre Dame and then suffered a mild heart attack later in the evening. Talk about going from the penthouse to the outhouse.

The coach’s situation reminds us that football is just a game. Sometimes football seems bigger than life, but it isn’t. Just ask Dantonio. It’s pretty difficult to coach or even watch a football game if you cannot breathe.

I don’t know much about Dantonio, but I hope he isn’t one of those guys who live at the office during the season. You hear stories about those guys. They are either stupid or truly dedicated coaches depending on your prospective. Football coaches have the reputation of being tough, but that might be questionable when the stadium lights go off.

Dantonio obviously received his wakeup call. Hopefully, he will stay away from the game until he is really ready to coach again. It’s a simple fact of life: football coaches are replaceable just like the rest of us. It only takes a few missed heartbeats to figure that one out.

Tuesday, September 21, 2010

Should the NCAA Pay Athletes?

The long standing discussion about whether student-athletes should be paid is gaining steam again.

Former NCAA athletes Ed O’Bannon and Sam Keller have brought lawsuits against the NCAA asking them to share its wealth with the athletes.

O’Bannon and Keller are intelligent enough to realize they are fighting against a billion-dollar industry with mighty clout and mighty lawyers. But even if reform happens in some way, then the fight is worth it.

Players are being paid now. It is just illegal. Boosters, sports agents and others are definitely supplying the money.

The NCAA argues athletes receive scholarships and room and board as a form of payment. I can tell you that Division I athletes aren’t staying at $30 motels or eating at fast food restaurants while on the road

Call me old fashioned, but I am not in favor of the NCAA paying athletes. How could it develop a fair system that would pay athletes on even a somewhat equal system? And frankly when you start actually paying athletes, you have professional sports with a different set of challenges.

I think the NCAA should provide a set number of scholarships to schools’ general fund based on sports Top 25 polls. All schools finishing in the Top 25 at the end of the season would receive the number of scholarships per final ranking. You could take the football and basketball polls for the men and the volleyball and basketballs polls for the women. This would give schools a tremendous boast in an age when major cuts are plaguing colleges and universities finances.

O’Bannon and Keller are providing awareness. Now it is time to put that awareness into action via the courts or some other element.

Do you believe athletes should be paid? Why or why not?

Monday, September 20, 2010

Why I'm Not in the Prediction Business

I predicted in this space Saturday that No. 9 Iowa would defeated No. 24 Arizona in Tucson. So much for picking the winner. I best stop while I'm 0-1.

Iowa decided to carry some issues from last year into this game--turnovers. Last year, the Hawkeyes seems to triumph over their turnovers and win some close games. Saturday night, the golden slipper came off.

Iowa played a miserable first half and then came charging back in the second half. But it was the Wildcats' party and victory time.

It was a huge, statement game for Arizona. Iowa suffered a big loss with high hopes for a special season.

The real question mark for Iowa is how it will react to the defeat. Will the Hawks put it in the past or will it lingering and negatively affective the rest of the season?

Coaches receive big paychecks and this development will require serious coaching attention.

The Hawkeyes should be fine against Ball State this week (no prediction), but the Big Ten season is swiftly approaching. With the likes of Penn State and Ohio State in the future, Hawkeye fans cannot feel as confident going into those games.

Certainly, they would have been pumped at 3-0, but the reality is a deep blemish at 2-1.

Will Iowa rebound?

Saturday, September 18, 2010

Iowa Will Defeat Arizona Tonight

Interest for the Iowa-Arizona match up tonight in Tucson seems quite high. There are some who believe the No 24 Wildcats will upset the No. 9 Hawkeyes.

But I'm not one of those persons.

The biggest advantage Arizona has is the home field. Plus, Iowa traditionally doesn't play well out West. Some also like Arizona's speed in this game.

But for the few Arizona pluses, Iowa has more. Adrian Clayborn is one of the top defense players in the country. The guy is a load and gives defenses fits. In fact, the Hawkeye’s' defense as a whole is stellar. Iowa also has a talented offense with several weapons. One guy who doesn't get much publicity is wide receiver Marvin McNutt. The 6-4 converted quarterback is a game-changer and always seems to make big catches and tacks on additional yardage after the grab.

Iowa has a way of controlling a contest. Some teams worry about the opponent's plans, Iowa worries about its own plans. The Hawkeyes had their way with Iowa State last week and will seek to dominant the Wildcats and punch them in the mouth.

This Iowa team is good--really good. Coach Kirk Ferentz will have his team ready and I will be surprised if they lay an egg. This is a big game for Iowa and an opportunity to show the nation that it will be in the topic of conversation for top five in the country.

Who do you think prevails in this game?

Friday, September 17, 2010

Who is Quarterback Russell Wilson?

North Carolina State's Russell Wilson is an outstanding football player. Too bad most of the nation outside the Atlantic Coast Conference have never heard of the junior quarterback.

However, Wilson put a show on for the nation last night under the bright lights of the ESPN cameras. He completed 26-of-40 passes for 333 yards including three touchdowns. He also rushed for 33 yards in the Wolfpack's 30-19 victory over Cincinnati.

These guy is a joy to watch. He is just an athlete. He throws a catchable ball, has a rocket right arm and can scramble and put up valuable rushing yards. Wilson is a total quarterback package.

Wilson has started for the Wolfpack for three years. He has been plagued with injuries and inconsistency. He has made first team ACC but has also offered forgettable performances where you ask why can a guy with this much talent be this bad?

NC State has started 3-0 this season. It has a solid offense and a good, serviceable defense. But if the Pack is to surprise folks in the conference and the country, Wilson will lead them. He is the type of player who can definitely carry a team.

Wilson's best sport may not even be football. He has played middle infield for the Pack baseball team and performed this past summer in the Colorado Rockies chain.

So in the future, he will have a decision. Right now, Pack fans are hoping they have another ACC first-teamer that will lead NC State to many victories this fall.

Thursday, September 16, 2010

More Heisman Trophy Talk

The Heisman Trophy brass made the proper decision when it announced that the 2005 award would remain vacant after Reggie Bush decided to give the trophy back.

There was some talk that runner-up Vince Young should garner the award. Well, Young finished a distant second that year, so why should he be elevated to the top spot? Anyone who wins the Heisman should earn it plain-and-simple. It's okay to have one year without an actual winner. It won't tarnish the luster of the award.

The NCAA could take a lesson from the Heisman folks. Whenever the NCAA finds someone cheating and takes away a conference championship and something higher, they will also make the school forfeit the games won. That seems pretty meaningless. Joe's College finished that year 5-6 and now it can claim a 6-6 record. But the problem is nobody cares or probably remembers. And frankly, Joe's College probably doesn't care either. So, NCAA take some advice from the Heisman folks and just move on.

Hopefully, all this 2005 Heisman talk can return to the past. There is a college football season happening and some players want to become the talk of the 2010 Heisman Trophy.

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

Reggie Bush Decision Offers Part Closure

Reggie Bush said yesterday he is returning the 2005 Heisman Trophy.

His declaration put to rest the status of Heisman rumors that were circulating for weeks. Many were wondering if the Heisman folks would pull the award away from Bush.
So whether he was encourage to surrender the award or did it out of his own will, Bush made the right choice.

The Heisman Trophy has always been about more than great football accomplishment. Character counts too. Bush did not display good character. So, now the Heisman folks can move on and decide whether to give it to runner-up Vince Young or leave the award vacant for 2005.

Bush can move on too. He has accepted the consequences of his bad actions while playing for USC. He cannot erase the actions, but maybe his conscience is a bit clearer these days.

People want to still blame Bush for the USC troubles. I am not saying that he wasn't a major player in the mess, but where was the athletic administration and coaching staff? I think Bush was a definite symptom at USC, but not the disease.

Some people also believe Bush is not paying for his sins at USC. This is not the case. He gave back the highest individual prize in college football and will probably continue some lingering guilt for his mistakes.

What do you think about Bush giving back the Heisman?